I didn't care for this eyeliner at all.
It applied nicely to my hand but nothing on my eyelid.
Tried holding it sideways and straight on as a pencil and it absolutely would not apply to my eyelid.
I have been using this product for 4 years now! Absolutely awesome. I have no problem putting it on. Stays on for 18 hours and DOES NOT SMUDGE! I have been using eyeliner for 25 years and this is definately the only one I will buy. TIP: You need to hold the liner sideways...it is not a pencil! You do not apply it like the pencil liners. Try applying it on the back of your had to get the right effect. I can get an extremely narrow line or a wide dramatic line depending on the look I want to achieve!
I don't know what happened with the 2 other girls, but mine was very nice. It says you have to keep it downside, maybe that is what they did wrong! I think it's a very good product, produces a dramatic effect in utlra black, but you have to be able to work it out because the tip is very thin!
It does not work 80% of the time. I wasted so much time trying to get it to work. I will never buy this again.