I love this eyeliner only kind I will use.. Best for taking the eyeliner off use Baby oil with Aloe..

the blue is super bright! a fun summer colour :)

Best waterproof liquid liner there is! Stays on really well, and takes some work to get off - best makeup remover to use is the Neutrogena one (blue bottle). Absolutely my favorite.

Stays on all day and keeps it's deep black color. Hard to find. My husband bought me 11 of them to make sure I don't run out. I have been using it for years. It's the best!

This is an amazing eyeliner. I have oily monolid and this eyeliner stays on all day and all night. I have tried Bobbi brown, Mac, Stilla, physician formula, Lancôme ... the list just go on. None of them work for my oily eyelid, by miday they will smudge and I will have a raccoon eye.
This eyeliner changed my life, I never have to re apply during mid day or worry about raccoon eye anymore.

I have really oily lids and this is the only eyeliner that doesn't come off. It stays all day until I wash it off. I highly recommend!

This is my third time repurchasing this product. Absolutely love it! Stays put all day & I have oily kids! No smudging, excellent pigment ( I have the black, blue purple fand green) blue is bright and pigmented. My favorite is the black - one I use most. Must try:)

This is my favorite eye liner. Easy to use and fantastic, longlasting coverage. Removes with facial cleansing. Dries quickly. No smudging. Love the colors. Forever is a gold/copper color (not like what is shown above). It is perfect for lining under eyes, alone, or with a touch of one of the other colors.

This is just like a mac liquidlast except for a fraction of the price. SO worth it.

I have yet to find a product that stays on as well as this one, and excellent value!

Best no-smudge, waterproof eyeliner on the market! I find that I need a decent eye makeup remover to remove it, but that's fine by me since every other eyeliner I've tried (Stila, MakeupForever, etc) smudge or run a bit during the day. The only fault is that the brush isn't the greatest, but you can just dip an eye liner brush into it instead. Easy to fix if you use a Qtip immediately after application. You can swim, dance, take a shower and still look perfect!

This really stays on. I use it on the lash line top and bottom. I have oily top lids and it still stays. Over time gets a little thick but I love it. Not too hard to take off also, just some soap and water and a little massaging. Great value.

Lasts very long, but a pain in the arse to remove. Never buying again!

I love this eyeliner! The formula is a little thick, but as long as you just use a small amount on your brush, it goes on beautifully and lasts forever! I've gone to bed with this on and have woken up without even requiting a touch-up! Still trying to find a remover that'll take this off easily though!

great colour (blue)
the consistency is a little thick
does not come off (bonus in my mind)
great product!

Nice product, has smooth gliding texture. Only thing I find wrong, if I make a mistake, it is impossible to fix without using makeup remover, which in turn removes eye shadow, which then needs to be reapplied.

For mascara you should try Maybelline's new Illegal Length! While the mascara is wet, you can pass over it multiple times and build length with their fiber extensions. Also, it doesn't smudge or flake and it can be bought in waterproof as well. It's an amazing product and makes your lashes look super long!!!

Firstly, this is crazy hard to get off if you happen to get any where it should not be ( need to use eye makeup remover). A bit of a sticky consistency and can look a bit too harsh. It does last amazingly long, but I will not buy again

I really like this eyeliner! I obviously didnt read up enough on the 'Forever" shade because I thought it would be more brown and less bronze, but other than that its really nice, and goes on smoothly to leave a cool shimmer. The only problem is the type of brush, its made out of individual hairs and I'm kind of used to felt tips.. But its still great!!

This product is great. It goes on smoothly and stays on without flaking until you take if off. You do need make remover to take it off. The only thing to watch with this is it does dry fast so there is little room for error.

I bought this product because the reviews were very good. It is waterproof and stays on which is great; unfortunately I did not care for it. I bought "Forever" which I assumed was brown, but it was sparkly gold.... as I am an older woman I was not impressed. Would be great for clubbing and evening wear, but not for afternoon shopping...lol. I also didn't like the texture (thick and sticky) and found it hard to work with; however, mine could have been older stock. I would like to know if all the colours are glittery.....

Love it! I bought both the black and Infinite, The blue is bright but perfect for when I was on vacation. In the sun and swmming and it never moved!

This stuff means business! I bought Everlast (the black shade) - it seems to be really long-lasting. I also like the brush, which gives me a nice fine line of eyeliner.

The liner itself is fantastic: highly pigmented and long lasting. It doesn't smudge or flake off. The brush isn't stiff enough, though, and since the product sets in pretty quickly, if you're clumsy in the morning like I am, applying it correctly can take a while.