So far, this is the best natural mascara I have found. It doesn't smudge, which is the main problem I have with natural mascaras.
The issues I found is that it dries quickly. I'm typically halfway through applying mascara to eye lashes on one eye when the mascara dries up on the wand and I can't apply anymore. When I attempted to re-dip wand into mascara to apply more to same eyelashes, clumping occurred. My tip is to do one half of an eye's eyelashes and then re-dip wand into mascara to finish off the eye. This is the best way to avoid clumping.