I really like the Midnight Blue color. The pencil does a good job if you want the smudged look. (A fine line becomes smudged after a few hours.) The liner stays on all day and washes off with soap. I do have some loss of coverage due to sweating or tearing. Be careful how far you twist out the liner as it doesn't roll back in once it is out. Also the pencil doesn't come with a pointed tip. Once I used the pencil for a while, I made a tip.