Love this cream shadow formulation, just not these shades.
Regardless, they've got killer staying power & pigmentation. I've got at least 10-12 in various shades. No primer needed with any of them. Can be worn alone, under powder shadow as a base, as a gel liner, or even to fill brows in (in the right shade, of course). There is also one shade that can be used to contour the face (Tough As Taupe). They do *not* move, for nuthin'. Nothing MAC makes compares to these puppies. Not their paint pots, or their paints, or their fluid lines. I've got a huge collection of cosmetics from all over the world, yet nothing I own - not even in the highest end products realm (of which MAC is definitely not included, except in price) - compare to these. These Color Tattoos walk all over MAC's abysmal quality, and then some.
I've never been a fan of Maybelline products, any of them, but I do love these.