I bought 2 bags of these treats as a Christmas gift for my daughter's 2 dogs plus 1 foster dog. All 3 dogs love them so much so that whatever they are doing is immediately stopped as soon as they hear the bag being opened! These treats have 1 ingredient, cheese, which is unusual for dog treats. I bought mine on sale so keep an eye out for that. These treats can easily be broken in half so will go a long way. I will definitely buy these again.