I'm a little surprised at the enthusiasm of the other reviews. I found this eyeliner inconsistently pigmented/textured even with a good shaking (sometimes very black, sometimes a runny thin grey), invariably flaked off during the day and often was gone completely by the day's end. All in all pretty average for a drugstore liquid liner.
The brush that comes with this is usuable. I couldn't get a REALLY fine line, but it was fine for making cat eyes.
I really recommend that you invest in a higher end brand cream/gel eye liner and a good brush, seriously. I've tried millions of drugstore liquid liners at this point and after going gel I'll never bother with another again.
At the very least, you can probably find better liquid eyeliners than this.
