This product did not remove non-waterproof make-up well for me. Although I'm looking for a gentle product that won't harm my skin, I ended up having to "scrub" my make-up off using a cosmetic pad when using this product - which is more harmful in the end. It left residue that was more visible in the morning, as the area around my eyes looked blackened. I think for people who wear full eye make-up (shadow, mascara, liner), this is probably not the best product. I did give it two stars because it was gentle on my skin and didn't cause irritation like a lot of removers can. I'd recommend L'Oreal Gentle Eye and Lip Makeup Remover to those who had the same problem I did with this product. It just doesn't remove all my make-up.